New York Subs

Reviews

• S Y.

  star star star star star 10 June 2026

  Best sub in town, by far. I eat here a few times per week and they always serve me a fresh sub, made with love and attention to detail, with the perfect fresh warm
  Bread and great amount of meat and fillings.  Yes the decor is dated but thanks to them for not raising their prices on us in years .... and their bathroom is always clean, and their restaurant is clean. This is a family owned and operated place. They know me and my family and treat us well.  I look forward to enjoying this sub for lunch!!!

• Susan R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 7 June 2026

  I can't say how disappointed I am in the progress of this place. Not only do they not fill the entire French roll with goodness but they put less meat on their sandwiches then Subway. That's not saying much.
  Their sandwiches are All Bread.
  Bummer, this place was good.

• Jane M.

  star star star star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  No Signs of New York Here:  Dated decor and no air conditioning did not bode well
  
  We decided to try it because it is the closest sandwich spot to my house. I was not impressed with the look of the place. I think it was designed and decorated in the 90s and has not been renovated or modified in any way since. The sandwich photos on the window and the sign itself are faded. Inside it was extremely hot. No one was dining inside. There were 7 empty tables and no air conditioning.
  
  We ordered two xl sandwiches - a pastrami which comes with mustard and pickles and a New York special which is Capicola, Salami and Mortadella. The order taker did not ask what cheese I wanted but I checked if provolone was included and he said yes. I tried to order a pickle spear on the side and he said they do not have pickle spears here. That blew my mind. I thought a pickle on the side is pretty standard for a deli. We decided not to order any sides or anything else until sampling the sandwiches. They were done in a flash. Our total was just over $17.
  
  Note on the sandwiches
  A small is 8" large is 10" and xl is 12"
  The bread was meh maybe a little better than Subway
  The New York had good meats but only one slice of each. The meat potion was very skimpy and the shredded lettuce way overboard. The flavor though was pretty good. It is not on par with Bronx or Cortina's but it is better than Subway and Firehouse for sure.
  
  Since it was "good/ok" and it is literally a pace from my residence, I am sure I will be back. Next time I will try the Monster Sub which boasts 1/2 lb of meat and 3 kinds of cheese for 6.59 on a Large. I wonder if I get to pick the meats and what type are included.

• Carolyn R.

  star star star star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  I love sandwiches! And this was good, but man, they desperately need a remodel! Everything tasted fresh, but the interior is so ugly! And hot! If they're doing well, the need to reinvest a little, so people want to eat there. Otherwise, fast and friendly service, good food, fair prices. I would eat there again, but def not a place to hang out.

• Jenise E.

  star star star star star 18 May 2026

  This place is an awesome hole in the wall type of sandwich place. Their menu is simple and easy to read. I got the turkey, bacon, and provolone sub and added avocado! There are there sizes to choose from. I got a large. This sandwich was delightful! Loved the bread. I would return.